So, my two "Make me pretty"s are a rocking chair I picked up at a church rummage sale 2 years ago and a footstool I bought when I was in high school. Sorry I don't have any good before pictures.
Here's the footstool in the back left of this December 2009 pic:
And I can't for the life of me find a picture of the rocker. But here's the after picture of the two finished projects:
The footstool was actually Callan's first DIY painting project, and I let both the boys help paint the rocker (so don't look too closely--there are lots of drips!).
Thanks for the tips and inspiration, Karen!